Let’s get it out there: roof replacement in Tinley Park, Illinois, comes with a sticker shock. Once you calculate the cost of tearing down your existing roof and waste disposal, along with the labor and materials involved in the process, even the cheapest roof replacement project is likely to cost several thousand dollars.


As a cost-saving measure, many Tinley Park homeowners opt to have their new roof installed on top of their existing one, so they don’t have to pay a premium for roof removal. This is called the “layover” roof installation method.


As Chicagoland’s leading roofing contractor, we want homeowners to get the most out of their roofing projects. And that is why we are telling you that there are a host of problems with a layover installation. Here are some of the most common ones:


Leaks are not always fixed


For most Tinley Park homeowners, roof replacement is the last resort deemed necessary by the fact that their current roof does not provide adequate protection. This often means that there are leaks in the roof, possibly rotting materials, and other issues. When a new roof is installed on top of a damaged roof, the source of leakage and other damage may not always be fixed, and these issues may persist.


Wood rot will worsen


Rotten materials will only continue to rot and may affect the integrity of your new roof — particularly when wood rots under asphalt and other materials as these areas are not easy to spot unless the current roof is torn down. The layover installation further masks the rot without fixing the issue effectively. This can result in irreversible structural problems with your new roof.


Overlooking eaves, rakes, and valleys


During a new roof installation, the eaves, rakes, and valleys of your Tinley Park home are subject to damage from inclement weather. For example, ice dams, snow build up and freezing-thawing of your roof materials can easily damage the eaves. These roofing components should be properly inspected and replaced if damaged. Unfortunately, a layover installation does not always recognize this type of damage.


Furthermore, unless your current roof is torn down, there is no way of ensuring that the ice and water barrier around the perimeter of your roof and in the roof valleys is working as expected. In fact, this 3-foot wide section of your roof is usually replaced during a new installation, although this is not the case with a layover roof. Ultimately, certain elements of your roof will be outdated and may not function properly when you install a new roof over an existing one.


Roof loads become unbearable


Many building structures (especially older homes) cannot bear the weight of two roofs. If you do decide that a layover roof is your best option, make sure you discuss the load capacity of roofing structures with your Tinley Park roofing contractor.


Sacrificing roof life


Perhaps the most convincing reason not to install a new roof over an old one is life expectancy. Any honest Tinley Park roofing contractor will tell you that layover roofs have reduced serviceable lifespan by as much as 25%. A complete teardown could be more expensive at first, but when you consider the life of your roof, it could save you money over the long term.


Professional roofing services in Tinley Park, Illinois


If you live in the Cook County village of Tinley Park, trust Prusak Construction and Roofing, Inc. for all your roofing needs. For over 55 years, we have been providing homeowners across the greater Chicago area with exceptional quality roofing options.


If you live anywhere in Chicago and the Suburbs, contact us today at (708) 422-2624 or fill out an online form to request a quote on your next roof replacement project.

 

Let’s get it out there: roof replacement in Tinley Park, Illinois, comes with a sticker shock. Once you calculate the cost of tearing down your existing roof and waste disposal, along with the labor and materials involved in the process, even the cheapest roof replacement project is likely to cost several thousand dollars.

 


 

As a cost-saving measure, many Tinley Park homeowners opt to have their new roof installed on top of their existing one, so they don’t have to pay a premium for roof removal. This is called the “layover” roof installation method.

 


 

As Chicagoland’s leading roofing contractor, we want homeowners to get the most out of their roofing projects. And that is why we are telling you that there are a host of problems with a layover installation. Here are some of the most common ones:

 


 

Leaks are not always fixed

 


 

For most Tinley Park homeowners, roof replacement is the last resort deemed necessary by the fact that their current roof does not provide adequate protection. This often means that there are leaks in the roof, possibly rotting materials, and other issues. When a new roof is installed on top of a damaged roof, the source of leakage and other damage may not always be fixed, and these issues may persist.

 


 

Wood rot will worsen

 


 

Rotten materials will only continue to rot and may affect the integrity of your new roof — particularly when wood rots under asphalt and other materials as these areas are not easy to spot unless the current roof is torn down. The layover installation further masks the rot without fixing the issue effectively. This can result in irreversible structural problems with your new roof.

 


 

Overlooking eaves, rakes, and valleys

 


 

During a new roof installation, the eaves, rakes, and valleys of your Tinley Park home are subject to damage from inclement weather. For example, ice dams, snow build up and freezing-thawing of your roof materials can easily damage the eaves. These roofing components should be properly inspected and replaced if damaged. Unfortunately, a layover installation does not always recognize this type of damage.

 


 

Furthermore, unless your current roof is torn down, there is no way of ensuring that the ice and water barrier around the perimeter of your roof and in the roof valleys is working as expected. In fact, this 3-foot wide section of your roof is usually replaced during a new installation, although this is not the case with a layover roof. Ultimately, certain elements of your roof will be outdated and may not function properly when you install a new roof over an existing one.

 


 

Roof loads become unbearable

 


 

Many building structures (especially older homes) cannot bear the weight of two roofs. If you do decide that a layover roof is your best option, make sure you discuss the load capacity of roofing structures with your Tinley Park roofing contractor.

 


 

Sacrificing roof life

 


 

Perhaps the most convincing reason not to install a new roof over an old one is life expectancy. Any honest Tinley Park roofing contractor will tell you that layover roofs have reduced serviceable lifespan by as much as 25%. A complete teardown could be more expensive at first, but when you consider the life of your roof, it could save you money over the long term.

 


 

Professional roofing services in Tinley Park, Illinois

 


 

If you live in the Cook County village of Tinley Park, trust Prusak Construction and Roofing, Inc. for all your roofing needs. For over 55 years, we have been providing homeowners across the greater Chicago area with exceptional quality roofing options.

 


 

If you live anywhere in Chicago and the Suburbs, contact us today at (708) 726-4593 or fill out an online form to request a quote on your next roof replacement project.

 

LATEST POSTS

Aerial view of a large home with a gray shingle roof, white exterior walls, and stone accents.
September 11, 2026
Learn how roof color affects heat absorption, attic temperatures, and home energy efficiency, plus what to consider when choosing new roofing.
Roofing inspector in a hard hat and safety vest examines asphalt shingles while holding a clipboard
September 4, 2026
Learn why a roof inspection before winter helps identify damage, prevent seasonal leaks, and prepare your home for snow, ice, and freezing weather.
Roofers remove old shingles from a white house, exposing plywood roof decking during a residential r
By Colten Miller August 31, 2026
Learn when to schedule a roof replacement based on seasonal weather, roof condition, and project timing for a smoother, well-planned project.
Gray asphalt shingle roof with a ventilation window, surrounded by tall green and golden trees under
August 28, 2026
Learn how a solar fan uses sunlight to ventilate an attic, manage heat and moisture, and support a properly designed residential roofing system.
Close-up of roofer using an orange pneumatic nail gun to install gray asphalt shingles on a sloped r
August 25, 2026
Learn how energy-efficient roofing systems help lower utility costs, improve indoor comfort, extend roof life, and add lasting value to your home.
Silver rooftop turbine vent mounted on a gray shingle roof beneath a clear blue sky above the white
August 20, 2026
Learn how to prevent rust and corrosion on a solar fan with practical maintenance tips that extend its lifespan, improve performance, and protect your roof.
Flat commercial roof with black membrane, rooftop HVAC units, vent pipes, and a forested autumn land
August 17, 2026
Compare EPDM, TPO, and PVC flat roofing systems to learn which option offers the best durability, energy efficiency, maintenance, and value.
Water-stained ceiling with brown discoloration near crown molding, showing signs of a hidden roof le
August 12, 2026
Learn how to identify hidden roof leaks early, prevent costly water damage, and protect your home with expert roofing maintenance and timely repairs.
A roofer repairs a steep shingle roof beside a brick chimney, replacing flashing beneath a bright bl
August 6, 2026
Navigate insurance claims for roof damage with confidence by learning what insurers expect, how to document damage, and when to schedule repairs.
An aerial view of a white corrugated metal commercial roof with multiple turbine vents casting long
July 31, 2026
Learn the warning signs that demand fast commercial roof repairs and see how prompt action helps protect your Chicago business from costly damage.
Show More