According to the 2022 NAR/NARI Remodeling Impact Report, new roofing projects recouped 100% of their cost in home value based on REALTOR® estimates.
But only if you choose the right types of roofing materials.
At Prusak Roofing, we've seen it all. For over 55 years, we've helped homeowners across Chicagoland select roofing that looks good, holds strong, and lasts for decades.
Keep reading to compare the pros, costs, and long-term value of the most trusted options, and discover which one's best for your home in this roofing materials comparison.
Asphalt Shingles are Popular and Practical
Asphalt shingles remain a top choice for Illinois homes, and for good reason. They're budget-friendly, reliable, and widely available.
Why Asphalt Still Leads
Many homeowners choose asphalt because it's easy to install and offers solid protection for the price.
- Affordable for most budgets
- Simple, fast installation
- Decent lifespan of 20-30 years
- Available in many styles and colors
It's a material that fits the majority of homes and doesn't demand a huge upfront investment.
What to Watch Out For
Asphalt isn't perfect. It's less eco-friendly than other options and doesn't last as long as metal.
- Can wear out faster in harsh weather
- May absorb heat depending on color
- Requires more frequent replacement
Still, for value and versatility, asphalt remains a practical, popular choice.
Metal Roofing Is Sleek, Sturdy, and Smart
Metal roofing is no longer just for barns or warehouses. It's become one of the most energy-efficient and durable choices for residential homes, and it's growing fast.
Key Benefits of Metal
Today's metal roofs combine form and function in a powerful way.
- Reflects sunlight and lowers energy bills
- Resists wind, fire, and heavy storms
- Lasts 40-70 years with little maintenance
- Available in modern and classic styles
It's also one of the most sustainable roofing types, often made from recycled materials, and it's 100% recyclable at the end of its life.
Is Metal Right for You?
Metal roofing is ideal for homeowners looking for performance over time rather than upfront savings. It's also a great fit for solar panel installations and is one of the more eco-friendly roofing options.
Things to Consider
While metal offers long-term savings, the upfront costs are higher than those of asphalt.
- Higher initial price
- Can be noisy in rain or hail if not insulated
- Might not suit every architectural style
That said, the benefits of durability and energy savings often outweigh the downsides. Metal is a smart investment for the long haul.
Designer Asphalt and Architectural Shingles - Premium Without the Price Tag
Not all asphalt shingles are the same. If you want the durability of asphalt with a boost in style, upgraded shingles may be the right fit for your home.
Why Homeowners Choose Architectural Shingles
Architectural or laminated shingles offer a dimensional look and higher wind resistance compared to basic three-tab shingles.
- Thicker and longer-lasting
- Designed to mimic slate or wood
- Better resistance to curling and cracking
- Available in premium styles and colors
They strike a nice balance between roof longevity and durability and aesthetic appeal without jumping to the cost of tile or metal.
Added Value Without Added Weight
These shingles don't require structural reinforcement, yet they offer a noticeable upgrade in both lifespan and appearance. For many homeowners, architectural shingles hit the sweet spot between cost and quality.
Ventilation and Insulation - The Unsung Heroes of Roof Performance
A great roof isn't just about the material on top. What's underneath matters just as much, especially when it comes to airflow and efficiency.
Why Ventilation Matters
Proper roof ventilation protects your home from heat buildup and moisture problems.
- Reduces the risk of mold and mildew
- Prevents ice dams in winter
- Extends shingle lifespan
- Lowers attic temperatures in summer
Without airflow, even the best roofing materials can fail early. That's why ventilation is a key part of every Prusak Roofing installation.
Insulation and Energy Efficiency
Good insulation keeps your home comfortable year-round. It helps maintain interior temperatures, reduces energy costs, and supports your roof's performance from the inside out.
We'll evaluate your attic's insulation and ventilation as part of every installation, because your roof is more than just shingles. It's a whole system working together.
Comparing the Types of Roofing Materials
So how do you choose the right roofing material for your home?
The answer depends on your goals, budget, and how long you plan to stay in the property. Each option we offer at Prusak Roofing serves a different need, and all of them are built to perform.
Best for Budget-Friendly Protection
Traditional asphalt shingles are affordable, widely available, and quick to install. They're perfect for homeowners who want reliable protection without a high upfront cost.
- Ideal for first-time buyers or short-term plans
- Easy to repair or replace
- Available in a range of colors
Best for Cost-Effective Style
Architectural shingles bridge the gap between basic and premium. They give you the look of high-end materials with better performance than standard shingles, but without jumping to metal pricing.
- Longer lifespan than 3-tab shingles
- More resistant to wind and weather
- Great for boosting resale value
Best for Long-Term Performance
Metal roofing delivers serious durability. If you're planning to stay in your home for decades or want to avoid future replacements, metal is a smart investment.
- Excellent in harsh Illinois weather
- Reflects heat and lowers energy bills
- Can last 40-70 years with minimal maintenance
Whatever your priorities, be it price, performance, or appearance, Prusak Roofing helps you make a choice that works now and pays off later.
At Prusak Roofing, we help clients assess every factor, from cost and curb appeal to roof longevity and durability, so they can choose with confidence.
Why Homeowners Trust Prusak Roofing
The material matters, but so does the workmanship behind it. That's where Prusak Roofing stands out.
Prusak Roofing has served the Chicagoland area for over 55 years. We're a family-run business known for old-school craftsmanship and modern solutions. Every job we take on is done with care, transparency, and pride.
We don't do shortcuts. We don't rush the work. And we don't recommend anything we wouldn't install on our own homes.
If you're exploring different types of roofing materials and want real answers, not sales pressure, we're here to help.
Contact us today for a free inspection and see why thousands of Illinois homeowners trust Prusak Roofing to protect what matters most.
